Written by 
Since the enactment of the Equality Act 2010, several legal cases have highlighted the critical importance of conducting thorough Equality Impact Assessments (EIAs) within public sector bodies in England and Wales. Failing to perform adequate EIAs can lead to legal challenges, underscoring the necessity of integrating these assessments into decision-making processes.
Inadequate or No Equality Impact Assessments
Friends of the Earth v. Secretary of State for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (2024)
In this case, Friends of the Earth challenged the UK’s National Climate Adaptation Programme, arguing that it failed to adequately address the impacts of climate change on vulnerable groups, thereby violating human rights obligations. The High Court acknowledged that a proper Equality Impact Assessment had not been conducted. However, the court dismissed the challenge, stating that even with a proper assessment, the outcome would likely have remained the same. This case illustrates that while the absence of an EIA can be a point of contention, courts may consider whether the inclusion of an EIA would have materially altered the decision.
Peter and Florence Fanning v. UK and Scottish Governments (2024)
An elderly Scottish couple, Peter and Florence Fanning, initiated legal action against the UK and Scottish governments over the decision to cut the Winter Fuel Payment. They argued that the reduction disproportionately affected pensioners and that both governments failed to conduct proper Equality Impact Assessments or adequately consult those of pensionable age. The case was granted approval to proceed, with a hearing scheduled for this year. If successful, this could lead to the reinstatement of the payment for over 10 million affected households.
Conclusion
These cases underscore the critical importance of conducting thorough Equality Impact Assessments. Public sector bodies must ensure that they rigorously assess and document the potential impacts of their decisions on protected groups to comply with legal obligations and to promote fairness and equality in public services.